• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Brand True

BrandTrue

Brand Strategy | Differentiation | Naming

  • About
  • Services
    • Brand Different
    • Brand Naming
    • Strategy Sessions
    • Brand Therapy
  • Tell The Truths
  • Case Studies
  • Contact

Battle of The Brands: Graeter’s vs. Jeni’s Splendid

It's another Battle of the Brands! This time, Rebeca is sticking close to home for an ice cream battle, pitting the venerable Cincinnati institution of Graeter's against the Columbus upstart of Jeni's Splendid.

Battle of The Brands: Graeter's vs. Jeni's Splendid

January 23, 2024 By Rebeca Arbona

It’s another Battle of the Brands! This time, Rebeca is sticking close to home for an ice cream battle, pitting the venerable Cincinnati institution of Graeter’s against the Columbus upstart of Jeni’s Splendid.

Battle of The Brands: Graeter’s vs. Jeni’s Splendid

Which brand comes out with whipped cream and a cherry on top? Check out this #tellthetruths video to see, then let us know what you think.

This video originally appeared in LinkedIn

If you enjoyed this video, check out:

Battle of the Brands: Patagonia’s Worn Wear vs North Face’s Clothes the Loop

Battle of the Brands: DOVE ZERO vs. NATIVE

Battle of the Brands: Rhinegeist vs. MadTree

 

TRANSCRIPT:

Hey guys, it’s Rebeca with BrandTrue and we are going to talk about ice cream! So we’re doing another kind of super regional battle of the brands, 2 Ohio ice cream brands: Graeter’s from Cincinnati and Jeni’s Splendid coming down from Columbus. And I think it’s a really interesting battle because they’re coming at it from two very different directions.

So Graeter’s is a heritage ice cream brand. It’s over 150 years old. It’s just, you know, so it’s steeped in our local culture and it has grown. My daughter who lives in Austin, Texas, can get some in the supermarket there. It’s been served in the White House since the Clinton administration, so it’s regional, very deep roots, but it’s excellent ice cream that’s expanded beyond this area.

Jeni’s Splendid is more like 20 years old and it’s started in Columbus, whereas Graeter’s is a family name. It’s not even connected to that in anyone’s mind anymore. Jeni’s on the other hand, people know that it’s Jeni herself, Jeni Britton, she’s written a book. She’s won a James Beard award because she’s taking this kind of foodie, flavor-forward, interesting combinations approach to ice cream. So it’s young and it’s brash and it’s modern. And let me assure you that there is space in my heart for both. I like to have both.

We recently got a Jeni’s in Cincinnati. Finally! Thank goodness! So there’s room for both. In terms of the brand name, therefore, right… because this isn’t about what they taste like… this is about the brand name. I feel like they both win because they’re both uniquely and richly ooh and creamily to make a pun, expressing their positioning and the way that they’re showing up competitively. So I think they’re both great. That’s what I think. Let me know what you think. Thanks! Bye.

 

 

Like it? Share it!

Filed Under: Authentic Brands, Brand Story, Brand Strategy

BrandTrue is trusted by brands like these (and yours!)

Footer

Our Mission

BrandTrue advises brands big and small on how to understand their underlying brand truths so they can connect with people in a powerful way that’s real, sincere and sustainably differentiating.

We specialize in strategies for brand differentiation, brand naming and strategic facilitation of powerfully effective work sessions that are also crazy fun.

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Contact

Feel free to drop us a note or call to say hello.

We’re always interested in meeting new people and any excuse to grab a coffee and chat.

T: (513) 604-9729

Menu

About
Brand Different
Brand Naming
Strategy Sessions
Brand Therapy
Contact

Let’s be friends!

Drop your email and get a free copy of our guide: How to harness the truths that crush your competition

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

© 2025 BrandTrue. All rights reserved.